Week 13

1. Which ideas from the
         video struck you as most relevant to your teaching of comprehension?

-connections, build vocabulary,
comprehension strategies, context clues, apply background knowledge, asking
questions, world knowledge,  use text to
build knowledge, text and hands on experience (aka background knowledge),
enable discussion, teach about the text, implicit and explicit questions, open
ended and complex questions, writing, activate prior knowledge, authentic
learning activities that are motivating for the student, progress monitoring,
meta cognitive understanding.  

 
2. What new instructional
         practices will you implement in your classroom?

All of these strategies are
important to use to help with the students growth of comprehension and reading.
I feel one strategy that might be difficult to use at first is prior knowledge
because when students first walk into our classrooms we have no idea what sort
of prior knowledge they might have or what level they are on. This strategy
might prove to be effective and most definitely would work better once you get
to know your students and develop some background knowledge to make connections
to.     

 
3. How will you use the
         ideas presented in this video to improve the comprehension of your
         struggling readers (students you are observing)?

Through modeling these
comprehension strategies for the struggling reader and maybe working in small
groups to work on developing the use of these strategies there will be an
improvement in comprehension. However we cannot forget about working with
students on the other aspects of reading such as vocabulary.  

            What struck
me most about this video was one of the first things that the narrator said.
She had stated that when we read we read to understand. We need to have books
and text that is interesting that will engage our students making them want to
read to understand. As a teacher we need to work on all the aspects of reading
to make our students active readers and have them to comprehend the text. It is
more effective when we teach multiple comprehension strategies. We first need
to explicitly explain these strategies and then model how to use them.  

DIBELS vs QRI-5

The QRI-5 and DIBLES have many similarities as well as differences. DIBLES is administered with a book but can be scored on paper or a digital device (palm pilot). The QRI-5 tests for various forms of fluency during oral or silent reading. The teacher can record miscues while listening to the student read orally and ask various comprehension questions. DIBLES when using the digital device to record data can account for a lot more than just student fluency. We can learn if the student knows initial sounds, phoneme segmentations, or even nonsense word fluency. This allows for the teacher to get a more in depth look at their phonological awareness where as with the QRI-5 this really isn't possible. However like the QRI-5 the teacher is able to listen while a student reads a passage and record the student’s errors. I felt that when practicing with the DIBLES having to listen to the recordings and not being the one prompting the student made it difficult to record the data because it was really fast passed. If I were able to practice with a student I feel it would be easy to become efficient in scoring. The one thing that would be difficult would be to remember how to score each of the tests that are available to give. I feel it would be important if using DIBLES in your class that you refresh how you would score each exam to make certain that you are competent.      

Week 8

• Discuss the components of an effective writing program and why they are important. 
• 1. The three main components of an effective writing program include personal connections, conventions, and inventions. Personal connections get the students interested in their writing assignments. Conventions give students an opportunity to go back to their writing and use editing skills. Finally inventions also get students interested and allows them  to portray their writing in unconventional ways. 
• How might you rearrange your schedule to create more time for students to write in general and, in particular, for students to write about their personal experiences? 
• 2. I would allow students to write about their personal experiences in relation to the topics being covered in the different topic areas. When the students are given time to work independently and have finished their assignments they will either be required to read or write about the topic area they were previously working on. This will not only reinforce knowledge, but expand their knowledge and give them opportunities to share what they already know about a topic and experiences they have had with these topics.  
• How can you create ways for students to make personal connections in different subject areas through writing? 
• 3. Let students get creative all you need to do is ask the simple question what connections can you make to the text students will find something no matter how far fetched. Allow time for students to share and discuss as well as write their connections to the reading. 
• How can student work help you decide which conventions to teach?
• 4. Through reading students writing samples a teacher can keep a running record of the different conventions that their students are struggling with. 
• When can you promote student inventions and experimentation with different formats in writing
• 5. After students are familiar with the content and have made connections and know how to go back and use the conventions while writing students can invent. While invention is not a conventional way of portraying your writing the conventions used should always be consistent (except on the rare occasion there are different rules applied to the inventive writing for example different forms of poetry). 

Analysis on student profile

This student is currently in the third grade and is an ESL student. I have no prior knowledge of the students reading capabilities.She was first asked to start reading aloud word lists starting on the first grade level. She became discouraged quickly but with a little encouragement she was able to completed the first and second word list. However the results from the word lists were not compatible with the scores she received for her oral reading. On her level one oral reading she was placed at an instructional level  an on level two she reached her frustration level. I feel it would be beneficial for this student to work closely with her ESL teacher on her English reading and comprehension skills. This will take time to develop but with persistence and reinforcement she will reach the current desired level.     

COCA

This informal reading assessment has some similarities to the QRI-5 but also many differences. The main difference is that students will not be reading the passages where as in the QRI-5 the students are reading aloud to the teacher or in some cases silently to themselves. Despite that the teacher is reading the text this assessment was developed to test the five dimensions of informational text comprehension. While the QRI-5 has this element we can also learn more information than just the students comprehension. How ever the procedure for administering the assessment is very similar in that there is a script, questions, prompts and a scoring sheet/guide. The main drawback of this informal reading assessment is that it only tests one dimension of the students reading, comprehension. Also there has not been research done in the way of interpretations and comparisons of scores. This is also limited in grade level and reading choice.Doesn't it seem more like a listening comprehension test?

Christopher Myers, A Writer's Story

I felt this video sent out a good message. Everyone has a story to tell
and everyone is different. We should recognize our students as individuals and
give them a chance to tell the class their story about what makes them
different. This is mainly reminding us to teach our students to embrace their
differences and if they possess a difference that they don't enjoy that they
can overcome  that. Mainly the struggle in reading which can be overcome
with time and practice. Do you think that you might run into a problem where your students might not
be as understanding of another students difference as you would have liked them to be?

Understanding the Big Picture

This is what we take away from a reading. We need to encourage students to focus on these big ideas to help them work through text. This will help them work through the harder texts that they will be faced with in the future. Fiction, Nonfiction and poetry should be made available to students and teachers should model reading and focusing on the big picture in the stories read together as a class or even in small group instruction. Ask about their knowledge of the big ides found in a story. Point out to the students how you knew what the big idea was by asking yourself questions and connecting the text to yourself, your experiences and to other texts. Teach students to ask these questions to themselves as they read. After reading a selection on their own have class or group discussions, follow ups, question sessions to really get an understanding if students are capable of discovering the big picture on their own. By the  end of 1st grade students should have the ability to do this with age appropriate texts. Reinforce that big pictures all around them in every subject that they are learning.  

Reading Assessment

This article spoke about the gap seen between state testing and that of NAEP testing stating that our state tests are limited. Although teachers might not have control over what is presented in the state tests they are in full control of what is placed on their own exams. Teachers should still prepare students for state testing to their greatest ability however in doing so to execute more thoughtful reading they should make several additions. These dont include limiting questions to only vocabulary, genre, and text organization but ask that students look deeper into text paying close attention to detail. In doing so there should be a shift from just recognizing to having their own interpretation and finding the intrinsic meanings. I feel that this is not focused on as much in elementary schools as it is in middle and high school what does everyone think?  

RTI

This article really breaks down the three tiers of the response to
intervention process and how it can be used for reading instructors. I feel
that RTI is important for all educators to
understand giving them the ability to implement it in their
classrooms. The reason I feel so strongly is because I believe this
calls for teachers to pay closer attention to all of their students giving
them the ability to accurately identify any struggling students. The sooner
these students are identified that quicker they can receive help. Ultimately
the goal is to receive extra support in the classroom for minor difficulties in
order to prevent these difficulties from becoming any worse or allowing the
student to fall further behind. The question I have is how do teachers
find the time to keep up with all of the progress monitoring that is
now going on in the classroom?  

video

In this session these lifelong
learners were working collaboratively to discuss different forms of assessments
that they use in their own classrooms and to comment on another teachers work.
These teachers seemed to have a vast number of ideas that they implement in
their classrooms many of which pertained to reading at home.

This session has taught me that
collaboration with other teachers and coworkers is key in helping to discover
ways in which might best help us to assess our students.  The most significant piece of advice that this
session offered was the need for getting the parents involved. Not only does
this reinforce and expand the knowledge learned in the classroom but can be
used as an assessment tool as well. We can build that parent teacher relationship
and ask our students parents to reflect on their child's reading and writing
capabilities that they show at home and anything that they seem to be
struggling with so we can center our force on their needs.

 Personally in the classroom the
assessments that I have been witness to have been more streamline and book
based. As in assessments for student reading levels, comprehension, memory,
fluency etc. One particular assessment I felt was affective was in a third
grade classroom where the students were preparing for the listening portion of
their ELA exam. The teacher would read a passage to the class twice and then
the students would listen the first time take notes the  second and when complete they would have to
write a short essay answering the questions. What was so effective about this
activity was the fact that the teacher would choose books that the students
would enjoy many times and relate to making the learning experience enjoyable
and take the stress away from the dreaded exam.    

 

Survey

 What is your experience in terms of working or friends with people from diverse cultural and linguistic backgrounds?

I have previously worked with students from diverse cultural and linguistic backgrounds.

Do you have experience in working with ELLs?

I have very little experience working with ELL students but the experiences I have had have been rewarding and very educational. For example last semester I was observing in the Patchogue Medford school district which has a high population of ESL students. Here I was able to work with some struggling readers to assess them to find their reading levels.   

Do you have experience in teaching ELLs?

I have not personally taught any ELL students only the minimal experience in working through my observations.

What is your perception on ELLs in terms of their learning motivation and performance in general and in reading and writing specially?

If not properly trained to teach an ELL class your students will not receive the proper motivation and performance in reading and writing will be weaker than it should be. ELL students need to be made to feel comfortable in that they can use their native language to express themselves when they fell they cannot using English. They need to be encouraged to use English as much as possible and to be assured that making mistakes is okay and part of the learning process.   

 What learning difficulties do ELLs usually encounter in schools?

The main difficulties that I feel ELL’s usually encounter are not having a properly trained instructor and having the conflict of whether to teach primarily in the native language of the student or in English.    

  In your observation, how do classroom teachers resolve ELLs’ learning difficulties and improve their learning motivation? What strategies do they often adopt? Are these strategies effective? Are you familiar with these strategies? Are family and community involved?

I have not currently started my observation for this semester but for previous semesters I have seen teachers provide extra support for those struggling learners. They will sometimes set up a table in the back of the room and while students are working independently they will announce that they will be providing extra help for those who feel they need it.

What intervention strategies would you adopt if you have ELLs in your class? How do you go about teaching the child? How do you go about reaching out to the family and the community?

If I were teaching a class that had ELL students I would work closely with those students in order to build a student teacher relationship where the student feels comfortable enough to ask for help when they need it. They should also feel comfortable to use the English language as much as possible to broaden their capabilities. They shouldn’t worry about making errors and their families should be as supportive as possible practicing English with them at home.   

hello there ;)

.....................yup